11 Comments
User's avatar
Dragoneye's avatar

Bravo Ben. In this age of cancelling, to come out this way is dangerous. Especially for one for whom public opinion is still so vital.

I'll offer two points.

First, and for the preponderance of readers here, regarding how AI affects creators. I am certain that the real value to being artists, is found in the act of creating. That AI might change that is little like the fallacy in seekers of spiritual awakening looking outside of one's self for it.

Second, regarding how AI will affect workers. Someone once said that every worker is a 'salesperson.' As you noted, AI is the shits at pitching.

Reading this essay made my morning. Thank you!

Ben Wakeman's avatar

Nice, I’m so glad I made someone’s morning today. You’re right, publicly talking about AI in an honest way is a fraught proposition these days. Thanks for weighing in.

Tom Willner's avatar

Thanks for sharing your deep dive into AI in these last three posts. It has been very eye opening for me. I really appreciate you sharing the quote from Claude answering your question about your novel. I feel like that is something everyone needs to understand about LLMs and most commercially available AI tools - they are largely based on prediction. I love using AI - I do feel like it helps me do way more work than would be possible entirely on my own. But it is important to remember that everything I get from AI is, as Claude told you, the most plausible next thing, not necessarily truth.

I also love your balance between artist and nerd, where underlying both is a deep desire to create.

Ben Wakeman's avatar

Thanks, Tom. You know me well — artist, nerd, maker of curious things, none of which is commercially viable! As you’ve alluded to, I think everyone is having to figure how how they use these tools and mileage will vary. BTW, it’s been too long since we’ve hung out IRL.

Michelle Levy's avatar

Most reputable publishers will reject manuscripts fashioned using these techniques… and as for the AI-assisted pitch, well, if you’re not the most ardent and articulate spokesperson for your book, then maybe choose a different hobby?

Ben Wakeman's avatar

Hi Michelle, thanks for reading and engaging in the conversation. You call out two really important points of contention here and I've spent a long time thinking about both. This technology and the way people use and feel about it is riddled with contradictions. While there are publishers who publicly make claims to reject anything that touches AI, the hard truth is that, within their ranks, there are probably individuals, likely the interns owning the query slush pile, who use Gemini to filter their inbox to only pull out "the good ones." More people use AI than will admit to it and where each person draws their line is always shifting. The proof is in the results — the writing itself. No one can hide that anymore with Claude watermarks and Pangram.

On your other point about writers needing to be the most ardent and articulate spokesperson for their book, I'd love for that to be true. In my experience, most artists truly hit a wall when it comes to commercially advocating for their work. The Fictorial pitch feature, doesn't do anything a writer couldn't do by reading a hundred blogs from literary agents or learn at a conference panel. The difference is it's interactive and tireless and there whenever you need it. I designed it to be a coach that has read all the blogs and knows the conventions but forces the writer to write the query and synopsis for herself.

Michelle Levy's avatar

Exactly. AI cheats the scholars and writers who invest the time, money, and energy in attending the graduate programs, conferences, and reading books and blogs, and actually growing wise and experienced, versus taking shortcuts. In other words, this method encourages trying to sound like a PhD without earning the PhD.

It’s been shown that using AI reduces intelligent capacity. MIT calls it “accumulation of cognitive debt when using an AI assistant” here: https://www.media.mit.edu/publications/your-brain-on-chatgpt/

One who wants to economize in such a fashion may succeed… and contribute to the dumbing down of society if they wish. Over time, artisanal crafted goods will take on higher value.

Ben Wakeman's avatar

I 100% agree with the dumbing down of society, at least initially. I think there's going to be a very long period of trial, error, and adaptation as we evolve and AI evolves. No matter what, I firmly believe that the work of humans will be valued more than it's ever been in history and the art we create in response to this new landscape will be much wilder and more distinct because there will be a hunger for that which cannot be generated.

Michelle Levy's avatar

You’re rational, and I love that about you. Calculators now perform complex math for us, and I certainly don’t object to those.

Ann Collins's avatar

You found the crux of it, Ben: storytelling is: “an intuitive act that requires judgment and taste, and above all an intuition about what will delight another human being.”

It’s like snow. Impossibly possible and magical and delicate. Deep and crisp and even. I’m not at all opposed to simplifying clerical tasks, accelerating tedious work or just brainstorming a beautiful bunch of ideas with the help of automation. But it takes a human consciousness, in the end, to decide what will delight another human by first delighting itself.

Ben Wakeman's avatar

It’s true. No matter how good these models get there is an invisible thing moving inside human prose that can’t be faked. There’s a beautiful symmetry to the whole thing: the text that Claude generates now has an invisible watermark that cannot be removed and human created text has the same thing. Thanks for being the first to comment on this piece. I’ve been very nervous about posting this series so it’s nice to have an old friend join the conversation.